Thanks, Andrew, for the article from Touchstone! Marvellous...
Here is one of the passages that stood out to me:
Three. An Evangelical convert to Orthodoxy, the son of a famous Protestant thinker and writer, publishes his interview with another famous former Evangelical in the tabloid-style paper that he edits. Though the two are old friends, the one interviewed has become a Catholic. In the course of the interview, the Orthodox editor unsubtly tries to press the Catholic towards acknowledging that perhaps he should go �beyond� the Catholic Church and into Orthodoxy. This same publication also carries on a sustained effort to win over Catholics and prospective Catholics to Orthodoxy. The most recent issue, which appeared in my mail while I was writing this talk, contains nine major articles. Six of these nine are, or contain, anti-Catholic polemics, including a lengthy assault on the allegedly �heretical teachings [of] Bishop Augustine of Hippo.�
The reference here is to Frank's interview with Thomas Howard in his now defunct periodical, "The Christian Activist". I remember reading that a number of years ago, and was struck by how Frank pressed and challenged his friend Howard to become Orthodox. It was a friendly enough exchange, but I have yet to see such an interview take place where a Catholic acted in kind to an Orthodox Christian.
Part of the problem is that so much of Evangelical and Fundamentalist Protestantism defines its existence polemically - "
sed contra" Catholicism (and Orthodoxy, to some extent). It is one faith in "protest" (hence the name "Protestant") against another.
Some converts to Catholicism and Orthodoxy continue with the same polemical posturing, albeit often against a new target. But I do not see how it can really sustain an authentic spiritual life...
In ICXC,
Gordo