Originally posted by iliana guadalupe:
... why not just be Catholic?
Instead of Byzantine, Roman, Maronite, Melchites, Hungarian, Greek?
Iliana,
We are all Catholic. Within the "Oneness" of the Catholic Church, there are 23 Churches
sui iuris or Churches "of their own law" (
i.e., self-governing).
Churches sui iuris It used to be that each of the various Oriental and Eastern Catholic entities was referred to as a "Rite" (
e.g., Melkite Rite, Ukrainian Rite); that was inaccurate since it misused the meaning of the word. For instance, in the example that I just used, the Melkites and Ukrainians actually use the same Rite - the Byzantine Rite. In more recent times, the Holy See has given recognition to each of the Oriental and Eastern Catholic bodies as a Church
sui iuris. Together, the Churches
sui iuris, including the Latin or Roman Church, constitute the Catholic Church.
RitesThe term "Rite" is now used appropriately to describe the form which characterizes the complex of liturgical services of any Church or group of Churches
sui iuris. Thus, each Church
sui iuris 'belongs to' or 'uses' or 'is of' a Rite.
TraditionsSome Rites are further delineated by the Tradition from which they derive,
e.g., otherwise generally similar ceremonies or rituals may be distinguished by particular prayers, linguistic variants, or cultural variations expressed in things such as style of vestments, chant, or other externals.
UsagesUsages, generally, only apply to the Latin Church; the sole exception among the Eastern or Oriental Churches is the Knanya Catholics of the Syro-Malabarese Catholic Church.
RitesIf you research how many Rites are extant in the Catholic Church, you will find various experts citing a range of numbers, from 4 to 8. It really depends on where you draw the line between "Rite" and "Tradition". At the most basic level, there are only 4 Rites - 1 Latin (or Roman) Rite and 3 Eastern (or Oriental) Rites (
i.e., Alexandrean, Antiochene, and Byzantine); that line of thought reflects the fact that all Rites developed from the customs and style of worship practiced in what were the 4 most important centers of Christian development - at a time when achievement of uniformity was hampered by the limitations geography and communication imposed.
In time, the Rites which originated from those 4 sites were either modified by those who carried them back to other cities or were developed further in those new regions. Some of the variations that arose came to be considered Rites unto themselves. Thus, in some lists of Rites, you will find 'Maronite'; in others, it is deemed a "Tradition" within the West Syrian-Antiochene Rite, which is where its origins were. The Armenian Rite had its origins in the Byzantine Rite, but developed in a state of relative geographic isolation (as was the case with the Maronites); accordingly, you can find Armenian listed as a "Rite" or as a "Tradition", depending on the author's perspective. (Melkite ritual practice had its origins in the Antiochene Rite, but eventually became 'byzantinized', to the point where its Antiochene origins are only a footnote reference in most discussions of Rite today.)
The following is a list of the Oriental and Eastern Rites and the Traditions associated with each:
1. Alexandrean Rite
Coptic Tradition
Ge'ez (or Ethiopian) Tradition
2. Antiochene Rite
East Syrian Tradition
West Syrian Tradition
3. Armenian Rite
4. Byzantine Rite
Byzantine-Greek Tradition
Byzantine-Slav Tradition
5. Maronite Rite
Hierarchical TypesOne of the ways in which Churches
sui iuris can be grouped is by 'hierarchical type', a grouping that describes a Church by the rank of its presiding or primary hierarch. The generally cited hierarchical types are:
1. Patriarchal Churches
sui iuris2. Major Arch-Episcopal Churches
sui iuris3. Metropolitan Arch-Episcopal or Arch-Eparchial Churches
sui iuris4. Episcopal Churches
sui iuris5. Churches
sui iuris sine episcopi (
i.e., without hierarchy)
To those 5 generally cited types, for reasons that I explain below, I've added 3 additional groupings:
6. Eastern Catholic communities with hierarchy, but not of a Church
sui iuris7. Eastern Catholic communities without hierarchy and not of a Church
sui iuris8. Eastern Catholic Ordinariates
Churches sui iurisThis list of Churches
sui iuris is grouped by hierarchical type (the Rite and Tradition are indicated in brackets below the Church name). I have added some brief explanation as to each hierarchical type.
Patriarchal Churches sui iurisMajor Patriarchal Churches sui iurisThose whose Patriarchal Sees are styled "The Ancient Sees”,
i.e., Antioch, Alexandria, and Jerusalem.
Coptic Catholic Church
[Alexandrean - Coptic]
Maronite Catholic Church
[Maronite or Antiochene - West Syrian]
Byzantine Melkite Greek-Catholic Church
[Byzantine - Byzantine-Greek]
Syriac Catholic Church
[Antiochene Rite - West Syrian]
Minor Patriarchal Churches sui iurisThose Patriarchal Sees which are not among those styled "the Ancient Sees".
Armenian Catholic Church
[Armenian]
Chaldean Catholic Church
[Antiochene - East Syrian]
Major Arch-Episcopal Churches sui iurisEastern Catholic Churches not of patriarchal rank; each is headed by a Major Archbishop.
Syro-Malabarese Catholic Church
[Antiochene - East Syrian]
The Syro-Malabarese are unique among the Eastern Catholic Churches
sui iuris in that, within their Church, there is what amounts to a "Usage", although it hasn't been formally designated as such. The Knanaya Catholics of the Syro-Malabarese Catholic Church are members of an ethnic minority (
i.e., the Knanaites). They are descendents of 72 Jewish Christian families who emigrated to Kerala (India) in A.D. 345, under the leadership of Knai Thomman (Thomas the Canaanite). They form an endogamous community within the Church, retain certain liturgical practices unique to their "ritual sub-Church", and have their own Eparchy (Kottayam), a non-exempt diocese of personal jurisdiction, canonically erected by the Holy See solely on the basis of the ethno-cultural identity of its faithful.
Byzantine Ukrainian Greek-Catholic Church
[Byzantine - Byzantine-Slav]
Metropolitan Arch-Episcopal and Arch-Eparchial Churches sui iurisThese are certain large Eastern Catholic Churches which are of neither Patriarchal nor Major Arch-Episcopal rank; each is led by a Metropolitan Archbishop or Metropolitan Arch-Eparch
Ethiopian Catholic Church
[Alexandrean - Ge'ez]
Romanian Greek Catholic Church United with Rome
[Byzantine - Byzantine-Greek]
Byzantine Ruthenian Catholic Church
(Metropolitan Arch-Eparchy of Pittsburgh for the Byzantine Ruthenian Catholics in the United States)
[Byzantine - Byzantine-Slav]
In the US, the Ruthenians commonly use the terminology 'Byzantine Catholics' to refer to their Church
sui iuris. There are two distinct Byzantine Ruthenian Catholic Church jurisdictions, one in the diaspora (USA) and one in the lands of its origin. Neither hierarch has been singularly designated as the presiding hierarch of the Church and there is no formal relationship between the two jurisdictions, analagous to that which exists in other Churches
sui iuris. Thus, each of the two is, theoretically, a Church
sui iuris, although the hierarch with the precedential title is situated in the diaspora (USA). (See the list of Episcopal Churches
sui iuris for the other jurisdiction. For purposes of counting, consider the two as one.)
Syro-Malankarese Catholic Church
[Antiochene - West Syrian]
Episcopal Churches sui iurisThose Oriental churches "entrusted to hierarchs who preside over [the Church] as per the norms of common and particular laws”; all such Churches are of the Byzantine Rite.
The presiding or primary hierarchs of such Churches are all of the Order of Bishop, but are variously styled: Abbott
vere nullius dioecesis ("subject to no diocese"); Apostolic Administrator; Apostolic Exarch; Bishop; Eparch; or Vicar Apostolic.
Byzantine Albanian Catholic Church
[Byzantine - Byzantine-Greek]
Byzantine Bulgarian Catholic Church
[Byzantine - Byzantine-Slav]
Byzantine Croatian Catholic Church
[Byzantine - Byzantine-Slav]
Byzantine Greek Catholic Church
[Byzantine - Byzantine-Greek]
Byzantine Hungarian Catholic Church
[Byzantine - Byzantine-Slav]
Byzantine Italo-Albanian Catholic Church
(Eparchy of Lungro degli Italo-Albanesi ['for the Italian-Albanians'] in Calabria [Italy])
[Byzantine - Byzantine-Greek]
Byzantine Italo-Albanian Catholic Church
(Eparchy of Piana [Sicily] degli Albenisi ['for the Albanians'])
[Byzantine - Byzantine-Greek]
Byzantine Italo-Greek Catholic Church
(Exarchic Abbey & Territorial Monastery of Santa Maria di Grottaferrata degli Italo-Grieco ['for the Italian-Greeks'])
[Byzantine - Byzantine-Greek]
For all intents and purposes, the Byzantine Italo-Albanian and Italo-Greek Catholic Churches now constitute a single Church
sui iuris, which is variously referred to by either name. There are two distinct Byzantine Italo-Albanian and one Byzantine Italo-Greek Catholic Church jurisdictions. None of the hierarchs has been singularly designated as the presiding hierarch of the Church and there is no formal relationship among the three jurisdictions, analagous to that which exists in other Churches
sui iuris (although the three hierarchs maintain an informal relationship to assure uniformity of liturgical practice). Thus, each of the three is, theoretically, a Church
sui iuris. For purposes of counting, consider the three as one.)
Byzantine Ruthenian Catholic Church
(Eparchy of Muka�evo (Ukraine) for the Byzantine Ruthenian Catholics)
[Byzantine - Byzantine-Slav]
The Eparchy of Muka�evo is an exempt (
i.e., directly subject to the Holy See) jurisdiction with no canonical relationship to the Byzantine Ruthenian Catholic Metropolitan Church
sui iuris [see above].
Byzantine Slovakian Catholic Church
[Byzantine - Byzantine-Slav]
Churches sui iuris sine episcopi These Churches are those "
entrusted to hierarchs (not of the Rite) who preside over (the Church) as per the norms of common and particular laws" (hierarchs
in locum tenens). All such Churches are of the Byzantine Rite.
Byzantine Belarussian Catholic Church
[Byzantine - Byzantine-Slav]
The canonical jurisdiction is extant, but
sede vacante since being suppressed during Communist rule in Belarus. There is presently an Apostolic Visitator
ad nutum Sanctae Sedis.
Byzantine Georgian Catholic Church
[Byzantine - Byzantine-Greek]
This Church has never been formally organized under its own hierarchy, due to the small number of faithful served by it.
Russian Orthodox Church in Union With Rome
Byzantine Russian Catholic Church
(Apostolic Exarchate of Moscow for the Russian Byzantines)
[Byzantine - Byzantine-Slav]
Byzantine Russian Catholic Church
(Apostolic Exarchate of Harbin (China) for Russian Byzantines and All Oriental Rite Catholics in China)
[Byzantine - Byzantine-Slav]
Both canonical jurisdictions of the Byzantine Russian Catholic Church are extant, but
sede vacante since being suppressed during persecution in their respective homelands under Communist rule. The Church's last hierarch was an ordaining bishop who entered into rest in 1996. As neither See was singularly designated as precedential, each is, theoretically, a Church
sui iuris. (The two should be counted as one Church).
Eastern Catholic communities with hierarchy, but not of a Church sui iurisThis grouping consists of three communities which have hierarchy of their own, but have not been identified as Churches
sui iuris, although they have the potential for such given their separation from the larger religious community of which they were a part prior to the political restructuring of Eastern Europe.
Byzantine Czech Catholics
[Byzantine - Byzantine-Slav]
The Byzantine Czech See was officially categorized as Ruthenian when it was canonically erected after separation of the former Czechoslovakia into the Czech and Slovack Republics. However, there is a decidedly non-Ruthenian cast to the See, in that the first and second (incumbent) Eparchs were priests of the Byzantine Slovack Catholic Church
sui iuris prior to their episcopal ordinations (although both are ethnic Rusyn rather than Slovack). Some sites already list this jurisdiction as a Church
sui iuris, but
Annuario Pontificio 2003 does not accord it that status.
Byzantine Montenegran Catholics
[Byzantine - Byzantine-Slav]
A See was recently erected for Byzantine Serbian and Montenegran Catholics. There are reasons to surmise that a Church
sui iuris might be designated for Byzantine Serbian Catholics. If that occurs, it is unclear whether Byzantine Montenegrens would be best served by inclusion in such, or whether their traditions and numbers would merit establishment of a separate Church
sui iuris.
Byzantine Serbian Catholics
[Byzantine - Byzantine-Slav]
A See was recently erected for Byzantine Serbian and Montenegran Catholics. Prior to the break-up of the former Republics of Yugoslavia, the Byzantine Church
sui iuris for Catholics in the Republics was designated as the Byzantine Serbian Catholic Church. Subsequent to the break-up, it was re-designated as the Byzantine Croatian Catholic Church; it remains to be seen whether the small Serbian Catholic community will be considered to merit
sui iuris status.
Eastern Catholic communities without hierarchy and not of a Church sui iurisThis grouping consists of: one community which formerly was routinely listed as a Church
sui iuris, but is not reported as such in the current edition of
Annuario Pontificio; an Ordinariate - a canonical jurisdiction usually erected to encompass faithful of divers Churches
sui iuris who reside within a geographic territory, but are unserved by hierarchy peculiar to their individual religious heritages; and, one community which has no hierarchy and has not been identified as a Church
sui iuris, although it has the potential for such, given its separation from the larger religious community of which it was a part prior to the political restructuring of Eastern Europe.
Byzantine Macedonian Catholic Church
[Byzantine - Byzantine-Slav]
This Church, which previously was routinely listed as a Church
sui iuris, is presently without hierarchy of its own, likely as a consequence of the recent geo-political changes in what were previously the Republics of Yugoslavia. It is not accorded
sui iuris status in the present edition of
Annuario Pontificio.
Byzantine Polish Catholics
[Byzantine - Byzantine-Slav]
The Byzantine Catholic faithful in Poland are a diverse community which includes ethnic Poles and others, including Ruthenian, Slovak, and Ukrainian Byzantines. Only the Ukrainians have a hierarchy. Ordinariates are generally erected for just such communities of mixed heritage, since they lack the cohesiveness of tradition and practice that would persuasively argue for establishment of a Church
sui iuris; however, the situation in Poland differs in that it has historical roots in Byzantine Catholicity. This, and the existence of a counterpart Orthodox Church, argue persuasively for erection of a Church
sui iuris.
Byzantine Slovenian Catholics
[Byzantine - Byzantine-Slav]
Slovenia, like many Slavic nations, had its Christian origins in the Byzantine tradition, but was latinized in the era of the Crusades. In the breakout of Eastern Europe nations, Byzantine Slovene Catholics have become separated from the Eastern canonical jurisdictions into which they had been assimilated. It remains to be seen whether they are sufficient in number to merit establishment of a Church
sui iuris.
Eastern Catholic OrdinariatesAn Ordinariate is a canonical jurisdiction erected to encompass faithful of divers Churches sui iuris who reside within a geographic territory, but are unserved by hierarchy peculiar to their individual Churches
sui iuris. There are five such jurisdictions; four are listed here (the fifth, Poland, is discussed above as an 'Eastern Catholic community without hierarchy and not of a Church'
sui iuris). None of these four has the potential to be designated as a Church
sui iuris.
Ordinariate of Argentina, Faithful of the Oriental Rites
Ordinariate of Austria, Faithful of the Eastern Rites (Byzantine)
Ordinariate of Brazil, Faithful of the Oriental Rites
Ordinariate of France, Faithful of the Eastern Rites
You may want to look at this site for more detail on the individual Churches:
www.cnewa.org/ecc-catholiceastern.htm [
cnewa.org]
If there are particular Churches on which you want more info, I have a list of informative links on each on them.
Hope this helps.
Many years,
Neil