The Byzantine Forum
Newest Members
SebastiĆ£o, NJC89, AsOnDryLand, Joe R, FrEugene
5595 Registered Users
Who's Online Now
0 registered members (), 69 guests, and 418 spiders.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Latest Photos
Church of the Holy Trinity (UGCC) - Brazil
Papal Audience 10 November 2017
Upgraded Russian icon corner
Russian Greek Catholic Global Congress
OL EuroEast II (2007) Group
Forum Statistics
Forums26
Topics34,714
Posts411,784
Members5,595
Most Online2,716
Jun 7th, 2012
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Page 1 of 2 1 2
Thoughts on Church diversity and greater awareness needed #405832
05/19/14 03:27 PM
05/19/14 03:27 PM
Joined: Sep 2008
Posts: 382
Cardiff, United Kingdom
Slavophile Offline OP
Member
Slavophile  Offline OP
Member

Joined: Sep 2008
Posts: 382
Cardiff, United Kingdom
In this article, I suggest that among Latin Catholics in some places, a greater awareness of people's culture and their churches is needed if the Church as a whole is to be faithful to her task of nurturing people in their own spiritual language.

As always, feel free to take me up on anything if the topic interests you - either here, or on the blog.

Re: Thoughts on Church diversity and greater awareness needed [Re: Slavophile] #405856
05/21/14 12:36 AM
05/21/14 12:36 AM
Joined: Apr 2014
Posts: 186
Washington state - Go Hawks!!!
T
Talon Offline
Member
Talon  Offline
Member
T

Joined: Apr 2014
Posts: 186
Washington state - Go Hawks!!!
Good blog post, Father. This Roman Catholic heartily agrees and, in fact, thinks it might be a lot healthier for the Church right now if the majority of it were Eastern, rather than the other way around.

I'm not sure how things are in England, but in many sectors of the United States (and presumably Canada) these days, Roman Catholic catechesis is rather poor. So, I would ask you to keep in mind that when you ask Roman Catholics to sort of "widen their phylacteries" as it were, widening something made of paper often only results in a tear, rather than an expansion, if you catch my drift.

Some of us have a hard enough time keeping track of what our own paradigm properly consists of. Asking us to add, say, five others to the mix is much easier said by a people who have a more static patrimony and solid catechesis than done by a people whose patrimony, by nature, evolves more over time and is not being taught well right now in the first place.

Does this make sense?

Re: Thoughts on Church diversity and greater awareness needed [Re: Slavophile] #405861
05/21/14 08:39 AM
05/21/14 08:39 AM
Joined: Nov 2001
Posts: 26,172
Canada
Orthodox Catholic Offline
Member
Orthodox Catholic  Offline
Member

Joined: Nov 2001
Posts: 26,172
Canada
Dear Father,

I would suggest that Roman Catholics today are in possession of the greatest possible awareness of other cultures and "inculturation."

The problem isn't that, but ecclesiology and that of the Particular Church specifically.

It doesn't fully understand in terms of praxis what being a Particular Church in communion with others really means outside of the centralized structure of the universal Particular Latin Church with Rome as its administrative (and controlling) centre.

Alex

Re: Thoughts on Church diversity and greater awareness needed [Re: Slavophile] #405871
05/21/14 11:17 AM
05/21/14 11:17 AM
Joined: Mar 2014
Posts: 44
Washington
2
2lungsambassador Offline
Member
2lungsambassador  Offline
Member
2

Joined: Mar 2014
Posts: 44
Washington
Well-said, Father. Your reasoning is sound and accords with my experience, which is why I went from Protestantism to Orthodoxy to (now) Roman Catholicism, which is my true home. The analogy i would use is from the environment: we do not need more monocultures; rather, the ecosystem works best with a diversity wherein each and all have something to give and something to get.

Re: Thoughts on Church diversity and greater awareness needed [Re: Orthodox Catholic] #405873
05/21/14 03:23 PM
05/21/14 03:23 PM
Joined: Apr 2014
Posts: 186
Washington state - Go Hawks!!!
T
Talon Offline
Member
Talon  Offline
Member
T

Joined: Apr 2014
Posts: 186
Washington state - Go Hawks!!!
Originally Posted by Orthodox Catholic
Dear Father,

I would suggest that Roman Catholics today are in possession of the greatest possible awareness of other cultures and "inculturation."

The problem isn't that, but ecclesiology and that of the Particular Church specifically.

It doesn't fully understand in terms of praxis what being a Particular Church in communion with others really means outside of the centralized structure of the universal Particular Latin Church with Rome as its administrative (and controlling) centre.


Also true.

Re: Thoughts on Church diversity and greater awareness needed [Re: Talon] #405877
05/21/14 07:26 PM
05/21/14 07:26 PM
Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 41
IL
C
Chirstopher Offline
Member
Chirstopher  Offline
Member
C

Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 41
IL
I am Dumb: Why do these only miraculistic miracles only happen in this one Church? Is someone trying to tell me something?


Re: Thoughts on Church diversity and greater awareness needed [Re: Chirstopher] #405879
05/21/14 10:00 PM
05/21/14 10:00 PM
Joined: Nov 2001
Posts: 26,172
Canada
Orthodox Catholic Offline
Member
Orthodox Catholic  Offline
Member

Joined: Nov 2001
Posts: 26,172
Canada
Dear Christopher,

Which miraculous events and in which Church?

I've studied miraculous events, icons, images and can tell you they are to be found in the Roman Catholic Church, the Orthodox Church, the Oriental Orthodox Church etc.

Are you just trying to get me started? smile

Alex

Re: Thoughts on Church diversity and greater awareness needed [Re: Slavophile] #405905
05/23/14 10:46 AM
05/23/14 10:46 AM
Joined: Feb 2013
Posts: 19
Florida, USA
S
shawnbm Offline
Junior Member
shawnbm  Offline
Junior Member
S

Joined: Feb 2013
Posts: 19
Florida, USA
A very thoughtful post, Father. I am an Episcopalian convert to the Roman rite, although I am very close to a Maronite parish not more than a mile from my Roman parish home. (I frequent both and know the clergy at both well). I can recall during my two to three year conversion process speaking along these lines with my fellow Episcopalians. I always would say that an Orthodox or Eastern Catholic Church would not be appropriate for an Episcopalian returning to the historic catholic and apostolic Church (I was the only one thinking it at the time, though, they only thought I was speaking esoterically) since the Anglican Communion was founded upon and nurtured within the bosom of the Latin Church and, therefore, any return should be there, where there are shared cultural and ecclesiastical norms, to say nothing of the Latin linguistic roots. I applaud your article on the same grounds--we should do all we can to foster Maronites and Melkites and Chaldeans to embrace and participate in their sui juris Churches, to the enrichment of us all.

Re: Thoughts on Church diversity and greater awareness needed [Re: shawnbm] #405906
05/23/14 11:05 AM
05/23/14 11:05 AM
Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 1,283
Texas
Athanasius The L Offline
AthanasiusTheLesser
Athanasius The L  Offline
AthanasiusTheLesser
Member

Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 1,283
Texas
Originally Posted by shawnbm
A very thoughtful post, Father. I am an Episcopalian convert to the Roman rite, although I am very close to a Maronite parish not more than a mile from my Roman parish home. (I frequent both and know the clergy at both well). I can recall during my two to three year conversion process speaking along these lines with my fellow Episcopalians. I always would say that an Orthodox or Eastern Catholic Church would not be appropriate for an Episcopalian returning to the historic catholic and apostolic Church (I was the only one thinking it at the time, though, they only thought I was speaking esoterically) since the Anglican Communion was founded upon and nurtured within the bosom of the Latin Church and, therefore, any return should be there, where there are shared cultural and ecclesiastical norms, to say nothing of the Latin linguistic roots. I applaud your article on the same grounds--we should do all we can to foster Maronites and Melkites and Chaldeans to embrace and participate in their sui juris Churches, to the enrichment of us all.


I entered the Orthodox Church from the Episcopal Church, and subsequently became Eastern Catholic. I have never looked back to the West, and cannot imagine that I ever will.

Last edited by Athanasius The L; 05/23/14 11:30 AM.
Re: Thoughts on Church diversity and greater awareness needed [Re: Slavophile] #405907
05/23/14 11:46 AM
05/23/14 11:46 AM
Joined: Feb 2013
Posts: 19
Florida, USA
S
shawnbm Offline
Junior Member
shawnbm  Offline
Junior Member
S

Joined: Feb 2013
Posts: 19
Florida, USA
Yes, I know some have done this, and I too thought of it. But, I still think the sui juris Church for many protestant groups is the Latin Church, not so much the Eastern Churches--for all the reasons I mentioned. But, and this is a key caveat, I begrudge no person, or criticize in any way, who opts to go from Anglican Communion to an Eastern Catholic Church. I merely suggest that from a juridical/jurisdictional standpoint, a historical and cultural standpoint, the Latin Church (Roman or whichever rite) is likely the realistic choice. Of course, that is just my opinion, being that the Church of England was born out of and rebelled against the Mother Latin (Roman) Church and not the Maronite, Chaldean, Syro-Malabrese, etc. Churches.

Re: Thoughts on Church diversity and greater awareness needed [Re: Slavophile] #405910
05/23/14 03:33 PM
05/23/14 03:33 PM
Joined: Nov 2001
Posts: 7,309
Falls Church, VA
S
StuartK Offline
Member
StuartK  Offline
Member
S

Joined: Nov 2001
Posts: 7,309
Falls Church, VA
What the Latin Church needs to avoid--indeed, to abandon--is "faux inculturation"; that is, the accretions of pop cultural ethnic elements to the Mass as a way of making it "relevant" to the people. Thus, we would at one stoke be rid of the Mariachi Mass, the Polka Mass, the Folk Mass, the Rock Mass, and all the myriad atrocities inflicted on us in the name of inculturation. The first step in real inculturation is recovering the liturgies of the Western Church, not just the Roman rite (though that is the place to start), but also the Ambrosian Rite, the Mozerabic Rite, the Gallic Rite, and perhaps even the Sarum Rite. These were the Masses of the the Northern Italian, Spanish, Franco-German and English peoples. Restored to them, they could take ownership of them once more.

Re: Thoughts on Church diversity and greater awareness needed [Re: Slavophile] #405911
05/23/14 03:38 PM
05/23/14 03:38 PM
Joined: Feb 2013
Posts: 19
Florida, USA
S
shawnbm Offline
Junior Member
shawnbm  Offline
Junior Member
S

Joined: Feb 2013
Posts: 19
Florida, USA
I could not agree more, StuartK. The Sarum rite is gorgeous and moving for the English--and far older than the rites in the modern BCP. I should Anglicans might take quite a liking to it as a liturgical alternative, but what it means theologically and culturally is even more important.

Re: Thoughts on Church diversity and greater awareness needed [Re: shawnbm] #405912
05/23/14 06:36 PM
05/23/14 06:36 PM
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 1,431
New England
Peter J Offline
Member
Peter J  Offline
Member

Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 1,431
New England
Originally Posted by shawnbm
A very thoughtful post, Father. I am an Episcopalian convert to the Roman rite, although I am very close to a Maronite parish not more than a mile from my Roman parish home. (I frequent both and know the clergy at both well). I can recall during my two to three year conversion process speaking along these lines with my fellow Episcopalians. I always would say that an Orthodox or Eastern Catholic Church would not be appropriate for an Episcopalian returning to the historic catholic and apostolic Church (I was the only one thinking it at the time, though, they only thought I was speaking esoterically) since the Anglican Communion was founded upon and nurtured within the bosom of the Latin Church and, therefore, any return should be there, where there are shared cultural and ecclesiastical norms, to say nothing of the Latin linguistic roots. I applaud your article on the same grounds--we should do all we can to foster Maronites and Melkites and Chaldeans to embrace and participate in their sui juris Churches, to the enrichment of us all.

Hi shawnbm. I started off LC, then in 2002 began going to a Melkite parish weekly. This is not to say anything against what you're saying, because I realize everyone's different: personally I would never leave Catholicism for Orthodoxy (or Orthodoxy for Catholicism) ... but I know that many people think exactly the opposite of what I've said, e.g. "I want to become Orthodox, but I need to still have a ________ liturgy." or whatever the case may be.

Re: Thoughts on Church diversity and greater awareness needed [Re: Slavophile] #405915
05/24/14 06:59 AM
05/24/14 06:59 AM
Joined: Nov 2001
Posts: 1,712
Private
T
The young fogey Offline
Member
The young fogey  Offline
Member
T

Joined: Nov 2001
Posts: 1,712
Private
Of course Catholics should know more about all of the church's rites. Before Vatican II, educated Catholics such as Adrian Fortescue and Donald Attwater, and the liturgical movement, were trying to make that happen. Fulton Sheen became biritual, celebrating in the Byzantine Rite. There are Attwater's books, Cyril Korolevsky's biography of Andrew (Sheptytsky), and a picture book called "These Are My Rites." The mind of the church is apparent: Eastern as well as Western. Because the church doesn't force me to choose Eastern over Western, I'm in it.

A Catholic Church that is majority Eastern? (As things are, all Eastern Catholics are 2% of all Catholics. No wonder most Roman Riters have never heard of them.) Fine with me, since the rites are still traditional. That I understand. The different theological schools of thought go over my head but I trust the church and know they're fine.

As a former Episcopalian (born into it) in the traditional Roman Rite I tend to agree that the Latin Church is ex-Protestants' heritage but of course I also agree with the majority here that some Westerners are called to be Eastern. I think we should canonize Andrew (Sheptytsky) and make him their patron.

Being entirely Eastern doesn't necessarily mean being anti-Western; the former minus the latter is what I believe is the authentic Catholic position and one of the church's selling points for me. Some convert Eastern Catholics' enthusiasm for the East is sometimes mistaken for anti-Westernism by well-meaning Roman Riters. (Although I have never met a conservative Catholic in person who thought that way about loving the East.) And, sometimes exacerbated by some thoughtless churchmen, sometimes it does sour into anti-Westernism and the person usually leaves the church for Orthodoxy. That doesn't lessen the church's enthusiasm for the East. I know that a lot of Catholics aren't enthusiastic about it, but I am referring to our teachings.

I agree with Stuart on getting rid of faux inculturation. Nothing wrong with recovering old Western rites, but it seems unnatural and quixotic if the rites (or, in Sarum's case, a recension of the Roman Rite) are extinct. (Actually in the 1800s the Catholic Church was interested in reviving Sarum at Westminster Cathedral but the English Catholic bishops didn't want it.) I understand from other threads that his idea is essentially to high-church the Novus Ordo along those lines (dump the guitar Mass and go strictly liturgical) and forget about the old (Tridentine) Mass, which is a valid opinion. Mine is that the old Mass is better.

(My view is in 50 years the Catholic liberals will be dead so traditionalists and conservatives will be all that's left, so the old Mass has a shot at being the majority in the Roman Rite again.)

Quote
...personally I would never leave Catholicism for Orthodoxy (or Orthodoxy for Catholicism).

Fine when it's rightly understood. Not indifferentism or two true churches (illogical: Anglican branch theory), but rather, the church gives born Orthodox the benefit of the doubt; they are estranged Catholics not personally guilty of schism, so with the church's goal of bringing all the Orthodox back, it doesn't try to convert them individually. At the same time, because of the true-church claim, it does accept such conversions - as the late Fr. Serge (Keleher) said to me, quietly.

Re: Thoughts on Church diversity and greater awareness needed [Re: The young fogey] #405916
05/24/14 07:39 AM
05/24/14 07:39 AM
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 1,431
New England
Peter J Offline
Member
Peter J  Offline
Member

Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 1,431
New England
Quote
...personally I would never leave Catholicism for Orthodoxy (or Orthodoxy for Catholicism).

(I say that because a lot of Orthodox that I speak with seem to assume that I'm an ex-Orthodox -- or else, they figure that I might as well be an ex-Orthodox.)

Originally Posted by The young fogey
Fine when it's rightly understood.

Yeah. Actually, when I'm being really circumspect, I don't say "I would never ..." but rather "I don't have any intention of leaving Catholicism, since I don't see a convincing justification to do so" although I could conceivably change my mind (and, conversely I can conceive of being Orthodox and then deciding to go Catholic -- although that's a weird double-hypothetical).

Page 1 of 2 1 2

The Byzantine Forum provides message boards for discussions focusing on Eastern Christianity (though discussions of other topics are welcome). The views expressed herein are those of the participants and may or may not reflect the teachings of the Byzantine Catholic or any other Church. The Byzantine Forum and the www.byzcath.org site exist to help build up the Church but are unofficial, have no connection with any Church entity, and should not be looked to as a source for official information for any Church. All posts become property of byzcath.org. Contents copyright - 1996-2019 (Forum 1998-2019). All rights reserved.
Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.1
(Release build 20190129)
PHP: 7.1.31 Page Time: 0.024s Queries: 15 (0.005s) Memory: 2.6356 MB (Peak: 2.7473 MB) Data Comp: Zlib Server Time: 2019-08-19 07:48:48 UTC