www.byzcath.org Forums News & Events Church News Head of Syro-Malabar Church Dies

The synod of bishops for the election of the new major archbishop of the Syro-Malabar Catholic Church [cnewa.org] has been convened for Monday May 23 to Sunday May 29.

(Source [hindu.com])

The Synod of Bishops for the election of a new Head of the Syro-Malabar Catholic Church starts today.

46 Syro-Malabar bishops are entitled to take part in the election.

Syro-Malabar church prepares to elect leader [cbcisite.com]

Were on earth did that country and western twang come from?
Stephanos I
I celebrated with the Malankar Christians and the chant was totally different.
Stephanos I

I know very little about the Syro-Malabar hierarchy, but I think an excellent candidate for the office of major archbishop would be the Administrator of the Syro-Malabar Church, Mar Bosco (Puthur), [clerus.org] 64. Already, he deserves to be known for his defence [catholicreview.org] of the rights of the Syro-Malabar Church. [smcim.org]

Alternatively, an interesting choice would be Mar Joseph (Kallarangatt), [bishopjosephkallarangatt.com] 55, Bishop of Palai and Chairman of the Doctrinal Committee of the Catholic Bishops' Conference of India. He demonstrates [smcim.org] a very clear understanding of the Catholic Church as a Communion of Catholic Churches.

Hi Fr.,

the Malabar Catholics have lost all traces of their Chaldean tradition when the Latins burnt all their supposedly-Nestorian heresies away. What the Malabars have now is only a reconstruction which is severely Latinised. St. Thomas Christians who refused to align with Rome sought help from the Syrian Orthodox Church of Antioch, and hence why you have the Malankara Christians. That is of course, before the factions and the move to the Catholic Church took place.

Palai is a very orthodox and Oriental diocese. Anyone who comes from there will sure ruffle feathers.

Mar Bosco is certainly not bashful in his comments, particularly for one who is serving as the administrator of the vacant see. It sounds as though he would be a strong advocate for the Malabarese.

Mar Joseph also is very expressive of the equality of the Churches and Rites. Either would be an interesting choice.

Many years,

Neil

A great truth.

Fr. Serge

It is a sad truth about what latins have done to st thomas christians. Still now its in bits and bytes of malabar rite and latin. The followers has less idea of its history compared to malankara factions who are strong in the knowledge of their past and culture.

To be broadly speaking both malankara (orthodox, jacobite and catholic) and malabarese are in dilemma with conflicts of beliefs and reality. Catholic - orthodox friction and factionism is the biggest problems now. All factions think they are right.


Latins : the society considers thems as lower caste as they are mostly converted christians by foreign missionaries. This hurts them.

Syro-Malabar : the followers are too much proud of the st thomas origin, calls themselves "syrian christians", but not aware that all st thomas christians are syrian christians. Most of the common malabar man believes they are the only st thomas christians. Many dont even know what is orthodox. The present day reality is that it too far from its original past.

Syro malankara : After the split from orthodox, people are caught between their orthodox traditions and believes and roman influence. Many approves pope and some dont. For them, undisputed leader is its Catholicos. Another hard truth that many of the families joined syro malankara during split mainly for getting job and other factors rather affiliation to roman catholicsm.

Orthodox : The problem of isolation still haunts people. People are still against roman catholicsm. Friction with Jacobite faction always makes them in a fix.

Jacobite : have similar problems of orthodox. Better compared to other factions as they are the only faction able to retain most of its traditions intact.

In kerala, the place of st thomas christians in india, syrian christians are considered upper class and latins lower caste

I am not telling my assumptions here. Having came from family which has all these factions, it was quite easy to know differences.

Another interesting thing observed recently is that each church head encouraging people to have more children to keep its head count ahead of other factions and other religions. Sometimes even feels that all the church has become more like business organizations when money matters are considered. The money spent on chruches here are huge. Its competing with fellow churches.

If given a supreme power, will restore pre schism church structure with pope as patriach of rome along with other patriarchs . "First among equals" This would enable disappearance of roman cathoicsm and orthodox and combines them to universal catholicsm.

Sorry for discussing out of topic here.

Thank you for sharing your interesting first hand knowledge. I will be praying for the Church in India.

Bishop George Alencherry, of Thuckalay

elected as major archbishop of the

Archdiocese of Ernakulam-Angamaly of the Syro-Malabars