www.byzcath.org
Posted By: Chtec Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/05/02 07:42 PM
I have been "lurking" on this forum for a little while, but now I'll stop that to share a little piece of news. smile

I found out last night that the much-revered Pochaev Icon of the Mother of God will be coming to Saint Tikhon's Monastery in South Canaan, Pennsylvania for the annual Memorial Day Weekend Otpust/Pilgrimage.

This will be a wonderful blessing for everyone who is able to be present!

-David M. Mastroberte
Website: Slava Iisusu Christu! [surf.to]

[ 04-05-2002: Message edited by: Chtec ]

[ 04-08-2002: Message edited by: Chtec ]

[ 04-08-2002: Message edited by: Chtec ]
Posted By: Our Lady's slave Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/05/02 09:16 PM
Quote
Originally posted by Chtec:

I found out last night that the much-revered Pochaev Icon of the Mother of God will be coming to Saint Tikhon's Monastery in South Canaan, Pennsylvania for the annual Memorial Day Weekend Otpust/Pilgrimage.
This will be a wonderful blessing for everyone who is able to be present!
-David M. Mastroberte
Website: Slava Iisusu Christu! [surf.to] ]

Oh please would anyone who is going say a prayer for me . How wonderful to be there and see that Icon
Posted By: griego catolico Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/06/02 12:17 AM
Christ Is Risen!!

I love the icon of Our Lady of Pochaev!! It is a dream of mine to make a pilgrimage to the monastery in Pochaev.

I do have a question though. Will this be in fact the original icon of Our Lady of Pochaev or a "pilgrim" copy of the icon? I don't see how the monks would want to let the miraculous icon leave the monastery to go out of Ukraine.

Thank you and God bless you!
Posted By: Chtec Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/06/02 12:35 AM
Truly, He is risen!

It will be the original Icon from the Pochaev Lavra. As Fr. Michael Dahulich, administrative dean of St. Tikhon's Seminary, explained at a lecture he gave last night at my church, the Russian Orthodox Church and the Ukrainian government have both given their approval for the icon to travel to the US.
Posted By: Daniil Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/06/02 01:59 AM
Give us back the icon!!! smile smile smile
And while you're at it, give us back Pochaev, too. You don't need it. It's too baroque and Basilian for the Russian Orthodox Church anyway.

Please take back the above comments with good
humo(u)r. Pochaev is one of the nicest churches I have ever been in. I was there for services on the feast of the Universal Exaltation of the Cross, and, let me tell you, it was out of the world. I understood what Vladimir's messengers meant when they said they "knew not if they were in heaven or on earth." It is an incredible place. Hopefully we all can visit it someday, and if not, then definately go to St. Tikhon's to venerate the miraculous icon.

Daniil

[ 04-08-2002: Message edited by: Daniil ]
Posted By: Chtec Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/06/02 03:43 PM
Quote
Give us back the icon!!! And while you're at it, give us back Pochaev, too. You don't need it. It's to baroque and Basilian for the Russian Orthodox Church anyway.

< tongue in cheek >

Very true, Daniil, much too Baroque for a Russian Orthodox church, with all those statues and western icons and what not... but, since the Eastern Catholics are called to be faithful to their liturgical heritage, it's much too Latinized for their use as well. Hmm, whatever shall we do!

I guess the only solution is to give it to me for use as my private chapel, since all that Baroque/Latin stuff doesn't bother me at all. biggrin

< / tongue in cheek >
Posted By: Two Lungs Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/06/02 07:17 PM
Quote
Originally posted by Chtec:


... but, since the Eastern Catholics are called to be faithful to their liturgical heritage ...


According to our recent instructions FROM ROME. wink


Quote
... it's much too Latinized for their use as well. Hmm, whatever shall we do!

I guess the only solution is to give it to me for use as my private chapel, since all that Baroque/Latin stuff doesn't bother me at all. biggrin

< / tongue in cheek >

wink

It is, of course, just my opinion, but I think we are not Roman and not Orthodox, but we are us! smile


Christ is Risen Indeed!

John
Pilgrim and Odd Duck
Posted By: OrthoMan Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/06/02 11:54 PM
What great news! But if anyone can't make it to St Tikhon's for Memorial Day but a trip thru the Pennsylvania coal regions you can stop in my home parish, Nativity of the Theotokos (St Mary's) Russian Orthodox Church in Coaldale, Pennsylvania.
There is an EXACT DUPLICATE of it in the parish I grew up in. Even to the jewel encrusted starburst that the Icon is encased in.
St Mary's is also a beautiful church inside to visit.

OrthoMan
Posted By: Daniil Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/08/02 02:37 AM
Yeah, I hope I don't make you feel bad, but there are about a few hundred exact duplicates around the world. However, they are good to have. Is Coaldale near Olyphant?

Daniil
Posted By: OrthoMan Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/08/02 03:44 AM
[ Is Coaldale near Olyphant? ]

Not that far up. Closer to Hazleton & Pottsville and next to Tamaqua.
Posted By: ukrainiancatholic Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/08/02 05:56 AM
I hate to be a stickler but the proper spelling should be Pochayiv, as it is pronounced in Ukrainian. Pochaev is Russian. At one time the monastery was a Basilian Greek Catholic monastery, but now its Russian Orthodox (MP)
-ukrainiancatholic
Posted By: Orthodox Catholic Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/08/02 01:26 PM
Dear UC,

Not only was the Pochayiv monastery Basilian (the time period in which it got all those Baroque accoutrements), but the Icon was actually crowned with a papal crown amidst throngs of Latin and Greek Catholic clergy and bishops!

In addition, the Basilians actually introduced the Cause of the canonization of St Job of Pochayiv at Rome! They promoted his cult at Pochayiv (that was impossible to stop) and Ilarion Ohienko in his book on Pochayiv cites copies of letters from the Basilian Archimandrite in Pochayiv to Rome about the Cause that was later dropped once the Lavra came back into Orthodox hands.

Catholic medals of the icon of Pochayiv, and I have in my possession one, also have the icon of St Job of Pochayiv on the back.

St Job was canonized by the Ukrainian Orthodox Metropolitan Dionysius Balaban. And my wife is a direct relation to him!

God bless,

Alex
Posted By: OrthoMan Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/08/02 06:40 PM
{In addition, the Basilians actually introduced the Cause of the canonization of St Job of
Pochayiv at Rome! They promoted his cult at Pochayiv (that was impossible to stop) and Ilarion Ohienko in his book on Pochayiv cites copies of letters from the Basilian Archimandrite in Pochayiv to Rome about the Cause that was later dropped once the Lavra came back into Orthodox hands.
Catholic medals of the icon of Pochayiv, and I have in my possession one, also have the icon of St Job of Pochayiv on the back.}

I find this fascinating to say the least. Since St Job was one of the staunchest fighters against the Unia. He organized brotherhoods and printing presses to fight it. He also fought for the return of Poachev to Orthodox hands.

If true, what this indicates is just how little the average laity & lower clergy understood what had happened and the fact that they indeed, were no longer members of the Orthodox faith.

[Our venerable father Job was born about 1571 to the Zhelezo family in Volynia (Southwestern Ukraine) and was baptized John. Having wisdom and piety beyond his years, John zealously entered the Ugoinitsky Monastery at the age of ten. He was tonsured exactly two years later with the new name Job. At the age of 30 he was ordained a priest, and shortly thereafter was tonsured into the great and angelic schema. He was then given the task of overseeing the Holy Cross monastery at Dubno. This was a difficult time for the Orthodox in a land so close to Catholic Poland. A false union of the Eastern Orthodox and Roman Catholic churches was declared in 1596. St. Job was a fearless defender of Orthodoxy, and under his direction, many Orthodox books were distributed, including the first complete Slavonic Bible. Due to the great turmoil, though, St. Job withdrew to the ancient Pochaev monastery, where the miraculous icon of the Pochaev Mother of God was kept. The monks there felt the sanctity of St. Job, and thus elected him abbot. He set about immediately to organize the brethren, build a stone church (which still exists), and start the printing of Orthodox books. St. Job was able to enlist the help of wealthy Orthodox patrons, but he also angered the Catholic nobles by his zeal. One named Firlei was able
to confiscate the land and possessions of the Pochaev monastery (and even the icon!). St. Job had to turn to the Polish courts for their return. The venerable Job also participated at the council convened at Kiev in 1628, which was a great uplift for the Orthodox pastors of Polish occupied Ukraine.
St. Job was a true ascetic as well as an able administrator. He would often withdraw to a cave where he would spend nights in prayer. His vigils were so long that his feet would bleed, and divine light was seen to shine forth from the cave.
Seven days before he reposed, St. Job received a revelation as to exactly when he would die. On October 28,1651, after serving Divine Liturgy, St. Job reposed peacefully. His relics were discovered to be whole and incorrupt after seven years, and transferred to the church of the Holy Trinity on August 28,1659. Dozens of miracles issued forth from the relics, witnessed by not only Orthodox but also by Catholics as well, into whose hands the Pochaev monastery passed for 110 years. After the return of the monastery to the Orthodo church, miracles continued, as they do to this day, as a service and akathist were composed to the saint. The Church has designated two feasts to St. Job: August 28, the uncovering of his relics and October 28, his repose.

Here is his Icon

]http://www.stjohndc.org/Icons/214.htm] [stjohndc.org]

[ 04-08-2002: Message edited by: OrthoMan ]
Posted By: Orthodox Catholic Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/08/02 07:09 PM
Dear Orthoman,

If you read Ukrainian, the Orthodox Metropolitan Ilarion Ohienko's book on the Pochayivska Lavra makes for a fascinating read on this subject.

He, like you, also says how ironic it is that Job's cause should have been promoted by those who would have, in life, considered him their enemy!

Job was clearly harassed by the Latins and opposed the Unia, to be sure.

But many Eastern Catholics, including Roman Catholics, didn't hold this against him. The Basilians, at this juncture (latter part of the 17th century certainly didn't believe themselves to be "Orthodox" but full-fledged Catholics . . .

They were the ones who brought in statues etc. into Pochayiv - no Orthodox consciousness there!

Job was a national saint in the eyes of the people, Eastern Catholic or Orthodox. Roman Catholics approached his relics and received miraculous cures, as is illustrated in one of the icons of the miracles of Pochayiv at the back of the Cathedral on the walls.

Pochayiv is still listed as a Roman Catholic shrine of the Mother of God in Poland as well!

I have a description of the Catholic papal coronation of this icon by an Orthodox writer in Ukraine and it is quite amazing. People lined up for confession for three days before, cannon were shot, people feasted etc.

Also, while Job was certainly Orthodox, he actually wasn't known for what I will call "nasty anti-Unia outbursts." smile

He repeated the Jesus Prayer constantly, and his publishing centre at Pochayiv was more concerned with the publication of Orthodox liturgical and catechetical works to keep the people grounded in Orthodoxy. There was actually very little of the polemical in them, although there was that too.

Again, this was not enough to "turn people off" him, whether Eastern or Roman Catholic.

To this day, the Basilian publication "Two Molebens" and others bear a picture of St Job praying with prayer rope in hand before the Pochayiv Mother of God. There is never an inscription beneath the picture to identify him, however.

Something similar happens with St Vladimir where, in his Orthodox Akathist, it is stated that he preferred "true Orthodoxy" over the "Catholic heresy" or words to that effect.

In the Russian Byzantine Catholic version, this is simply changed to "the beautiful services of the Christian East."

Personally, given the number of miracles St Job has granted to so many Orthodox, Eastern Catholic and Roman Catholic venerators, I guess he just isn't one to discriminate!

But if you read Ukrainian, Metropolitan Ohienko's book is terrific!

Alex
Posted By: RichC Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/08/02 07:32 PM
Quote
Originally posted by OrthoMan:
A false union of the Eastern Orthodox and Roman Catholic churches was declared in 1596.

What was "false" about it?

The fact that it happened peacemeal (eparchy by eparchy), or that it was declared by the Orthodox Rus' bishops without the consent of the people?

Or perhaps that it was not a true union, in that the (former) Orthodox did not truly accept (Roman) Catholicism but only the appearance of it? But if Uniates are Roman Catholics as you say, doesn't that mean that they have fully accepted every tenet and precept of Roman Catholicism? So where's the falsehood in that?

I guess that means that in addition to being Roman Catholic heretics, Uniates are even worse in that they are also actively involved in deception.

Perhaps the author is asserting that "false union" was imposed by force, and when the force was lifted the Unia ceased to be?

[ 04-08-2002: Message edited by: RichC ]
Posted By: Orthodox Catholic Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/08/02 07:57 PM
Dear RichC,

Actually, your point about "Uniates" being worse than RC's is exactly the point Orthodox polemicists always make.

For example, in the Orthodox "Rudder," this is the point that is made about Eastern Catholics there in the footnotes etc.

You are right on! (Why don't I feel good about that?)

And your point about the consent of the people, that is true.

However, no one originally asked the people's consent when Kyivan Rus' was baptized into Orthodox Christianity.

The upper echelons of society then hardly ever asked the consent of the lower echelons concerning anything.

The Union of Brest-Litovsk was notable in this respect in that the bishops didn't consult with their Princes, such as Constantine Ostrozhky and others.

This, rather than the idea of union with Rome, is what set them off against the bishops and "their" Roman union.

St Athanasius of Brest, martyred by the Catholics for opposing the union, was actually against not the union itself, but against the use of force in imposing it on the populace (as is evident from his diary and his speech in the Polish parliament at which he distributed to everyone, Protestant and Catholic alike, copies of a Miraculous Icon of the Mother of God "Kupyatitska").

Further evidence of this is found in the fact that Ukrainian Catholics originally venerated St Athanasius as a national saint and hero who opposed their enemies.

It was much later that his cult was rooted out of the Ukrainian Catholic practice.

The Union was "False" and "True" depending on who looks at it and from what angle.

That it was considered "False" from the Orthodox theological angle was something that came about much later.

The idea of union with Rome was bantered about by the Orthodox Princes as well as the bishops of the time in response to the control exerted over them not by Poland, but by Constantinople and the Greeks, again this is well documented in Met. Ilarion's books (but you have to read Ukrainian!).

It became a "False" thing politically when it divided the country and caused problems, including the Latinization and denationalization of the Ukrainian aristocracy.

It became "True" in the 20th century as an instrument of increased Ukrainian identification and nationalism. "True" in other ways too, including what Basil Lypkivsky on the Orthodox side said was "a phenomenon that was justifiable in its times."

Orthodox today tend to do a knee-jerk reaction, in general, against the Unia, but not all.

I was myself told by a Patriarchal Russian Orthodox priest to be "more open-minded" about the Unia smile as God allowed it and it will serve His purposes in ways he and other Orthodox may not see.

Again, one can't blame the Orthodox for accusing the Unia of being "false" especially since it is a kind of historical and living testimony on our part of the "insufficiency" of Orthodoxy, that it is in "schism" etc.

I personally would never use "False" to describe anyone's religious identity or Church etc.

And that's because I'm a nice guy . . . smile

Alex
Posted By: Robert K. Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/09/02 12:14 AM
Why does everbody always blame the Basilians for all the probelms in the Greek Catholic Church? This order has been since its creation, full of devout men who have sacrificed much in order to advance the cause of the Byzantine Church in communion with Rome. All the sufferings and hardships that they endored for the salvation and protection of their flocks and all anybody can do is lay on heaps of critisicm about "Latinizations" on them.

Why if it wasnt for the Basilians Id wonder what the Greek Catholic Church would be like today? It probably wouldnt even exist!

On a secondary note, has anyone ever been to the Basilian monastery in Matawan, New Jersey? If so, how is it? I have been trying to get some info from them, especially pictures of the monastery and shrine. But unfortunatly they have no web page.

Robert K.
Posted By: Anonymous Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/09/02 01:12 AM
Christ is Risen!

The thoughts on the Unia (and the history of the Basilian community) are very interesting, but I fear that those questions have deviated from the announced topic in the title. Perhaps they should have threads of their own?

I for one, would like to know more about the icon of the Mother of God of Pochaev? Does anyone know the history of this icon?

Elias
Posted By: griego catolico Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/09/02 02:29 AM
[QUOTE]Originally posted by Orthodox Catholic:
[QB]Dear UC,

Not only was the Pochayiv monastery Basilian (the time period in which it got all those Baroque accoutrements), but the Icon was actually crowned with a papal crown amidst throngs of Latin and Greek Catholic clergy and bishops!

Alex,
Christ is Risen!
Many months ago,I was going through some very old issues of Eastern Churches Quarterly and came across an article on Metropolitan Sheptitsky and the Ukrainian Catholic Church. In a footnote to that article, it stated that the original icon of Our Lady of Pochayiv was taken by the Basilians when they had to leave the monastery and a copy was put in its place. I found this surprising!
Have you ever heard about this before? Is it credible?

God bless you,
griego
Posted By: OrthoMan Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/09/02 03:55 AM
[I for one, would like to know more about the icon of the Mother of God of Pochaev? Does anyone know the history of this icon?

Elias]

Information on the Pochaev Icon of the Birthgiver of God is available on
the Orthodox Church in America website, at the following URLs:

http://www.oca.org/pages/orth_chri/Feasts-and-Saints/July/Jul-23.html
http://www.oca.org/pages/orth_chri/Feasts-and-Saints/September/Sep-08.html#p
ochaev
Christos Voskryesye

Dear friends,

An excellent booklet on the Pochaev Icon is "The Miraculous Icon of Pocaev" by John Bird. It is availible from Veritas Press in Ireland. The 101 Foundation may still have some copies.

I developed a devotion to the Bogoroditza Pochayevskaya after I purchased a beautiful Pochaev medal at the local Ukrainian Art Center a few years ago. It is attached to my "Chotki Bogoroditzu" which I always carry.

I also have a lovely holy card of St. Josaphat. He is floating over Pochaev Monastery. I believe this card is still sold by Basilian Press in Toronto. Hieromartyr Nikolaj Carneckji also had a devotion to the Virgin of Pochaev. He visited the lavra in 1927 or 1928, on an early trip through Volhynia. There is a brief account of this visit in the life by Stephen Bachtalowsky.

Hieromartyr Nikolaj (1884-1959) was moved by the great faith of the Ukrainian people. They came in great numbers to the monastery to lay their petitions before the Mother of God. The Russian monks made little provision for them. They preached only in Russian. Only two priests were hearing confession. The Russians were a minority in Volhynia.

Presviataya Bogoroditza Fatimskaya, spasi nas.
Presviataya Bogoroditza Pochayevskaya, spasi nas.
RusOrthCath martyrs and confessors, pray for us.

[ 04-16-2002: Message edited by: PaulOrthCathConfessor ]

[ 04-16-2002: Message edited by: PaulOrthCathConfessor ]
Christos Voskryesye!

Two more Russian martyrs were devoted to the Virgin of Pochaev. One was the Russian Catholic Old Believer priest monk Hieromartyr Potapij Emel'janov (1884-1936) and the Orthodox Carpatho-Rusyn priest monk Hieromartyr Maksym Sandovych (1886-1914.)

Presviataya Bogoroditza Fatimskaya, spasi nas.
RusOrthCath martyrs and confessors, pray for us.
Posted By: Orthodox Catholic Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/17/02 01:45 PM
Dear Griego,

Yes, the theory that the Basilian Fathers took the Pochayiv Icon was once circulated, but has proven false. The original is still at the Pochayiv Monastery in Ukraine.

In fact, there is another miraculous Icon of Pochayiv there, an icon that depicts the Mother of God over the rock on which Her Footprint was imprinted.

This miraculous icon was sent to the Lavra from Kyiv in 1859 following an answer to the Kyivans' prayer to stop a cholera epidemic there.

One problem, as with other Shrines, is that Pochayiv is claimed by both Catholics and Orthodox, although it is certainly an Orthodox Shrine, and of this there can be no doubt.

But the official position of the Ukrainian Catholic Church today is to recognize it as an Orthodox Shrine and to say that Catholics share in the great veneration to it.

The three main Shrines of the Lavra are: The miraculous Icon, the Footprint of Our Lady from which holy Water flows and the relics of St Job of Pochayiv.

The Footprint is held in great devotion and the special Communion Loaves used there are stamped with the image of Our Lady's Footprint.

To venerate the Footprint, as is mentioned in the Way of the Pilgrim, is to ask Our Lady to guide our own footsteps in the path toward God.

As the OCA pages Orthoman has listed state, a monk and a shepherd by the name of Ivan Bossiy, saw the Mother of God in the midst of a flaming aureole on the mountain of Pochayiv, with a Crown and a sceptre.

She said nothing and after the apparition disappeared they found Her footprint imbedded in the rock over which She appeared and water flowed from it.

This is, in fact, the "Lourdes" of the East.

Anna Hoyska received the icon from a Greek Patriarch and donated it to the developing monastery where pilgrimages began in earnest immediately following.

The Church of the Holy Trinity is no longer there, but was built through the charity of the Domashevsky family. The only representation we have of it, in fact, is in the family portrait of the Domashevsky.

My ancestor, Auguste Yablonowsky, was also devoted to the Shrine and donated generously to the Lavra. My wife, Tanya, is a descendant of the Orthodox Metropolitan of Kyiv, Dionysius Balaban, who glorified St Job a saint in 1654.

On the back wall of the Cathedral there are represented 21 miracles of the Pochayiv Mother of God, one of which involved the curing of a blind Polish Catholic woman who later became Orthodox in thanksgiving.

There is also a beautiful Icon of the Choir of the Saints of Volyn: Sts. Stephen and Amphilochius of Vladimir in Volyn, St Theodore prince of Ostrih, St Juliana Olshanska, St Job of Pochayiv, St Macarius of Kaniv, St Yaropolk prince of Vladimir in Volyn.

(As a side-note to Paul - St Josaphat was also a saint from Volyn, but Catholic.)

There is a special Akathist to Our Lady of Pochayiv and to St Job of Pochayiv that St John of Kronstadt press has available.

The miracle of the repelling of the cannon-balls at Pochayiv through the Mother of God and St Job is celebrated with special popular songs.

The people came out and began singing the Akathist to the Mother of God (Annunciation) and having read the first Kondak, the miracle and apparition occurred. As a result, this Kondak is said as a separate prayer by Orthodox Christians to this day.

Also, it should be noted that a number of the Turks who witnessed this miracle became Orthodox Christians and Monks at the Pochayiv Lavra.

As a sidenote to our Pro-Catholic friend, Robert K. smile - I'm not against the Basilians, Robert. I served in a Basilian Church for seven years as an altar boy.

The fact of their historic Latinization as a religious Order is simply that, something that applies to the Redemptorists and others. And I have Redemptorists in my family.

There are many among them who fight Latinization in their Order, such as Fr. Basil Zinko OSBM of Brazil who is very dedicated to the Byzantinization of the full Eastern Horologion, Fr.Julian Katriy, OSBM who has written so widely about the purity of Byzantine Church liturgical traditions and Fr. Meletius Soloviy, OSBM (+memory eternal!) who wrote so much about the same.

Metropolitan Ilarion Ohienko of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church attacked the historic latinizations of the Basilians at Pochayiv, their taking it over etc.

But he had nothing against the Basilians of this century insofar as their Ukrainian identity went, and indeed the Basilian Press at Zhovkva (where St Nicholas Zahorivsky, the Orthodox Hieroconfessor died) published a number of his literary works.

Again, I have never come across an Orthodox who was so defensive of the Ukrainian Catholic Church!

You are more papal than I, my friend. And I say that with the utmost of respect and fondness!

Alex
Posted By: Mor Ephrem Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/17/02 02:35 PM
Quote
Originally posted by Orthodox Catholic:
This is, in fact, the "Lourdes" of the East.

Depends on what "East" you mean. If you mean "East" as in Eastern Christianity, OK. If not, then I'm sorry, but this honour goes to the shrine of Our Lady of Good Health at Vailankanni, in India. It's been called such by, among other people, the Pope. :p

No hard feelings? smile

http://www.annaivailankanni.org/index.html

The Virgin looks awesome in a sari.
Posted By: Orthodox Catholic Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/17/02 02:43 PM
Dear Catholicos,

Yes, I venerate that miraculous Shrine as well, not just you smile .

I meant "East" in the Byzantine sense, and I am again hoisted on my own petard . . .good for you.

I was just trying to see if you were lurking out there . . .ooops I can feel my nose growing again!

And also our friends should remember that since Ukraine is now independent, the term is really "Pochayiv" rather than "Pochaev."

I say this to protect you against the anger of any of those nationalistic Ukrainians out there, you know . . . smile

Alex
Posted By: Amadeus Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/17/02 04:03 PM
For whatever its worth, I second Mor Ephrem here. biggrin

The "Shrine [elevated to a Basilica by Bl. Pope John XXIII in 1962] of Our Lady of Good Health" is, indeed, the "Lourdes of the East."

Filipino Catholics have been going on pilgrimage to the Shrine annually, especially this year when it was the focus of the Catholic Church's annual celebrations of the "World Day of the Sick" held on Feburay 11th.

BTW, Mor Ephrem, I noticed that the parish celebrates/offers the Holy Mass 6 times daily, Mondays thru Fridays, 7 times on Saturdays, and 8 times on Sundays! (I think, this partially answers your doubt as to whether daily Masses are being celebrated in India.) But considering that there are an estimated 20 million pilgrims to the Shrine annually, the number of Masses celebrated daily in this parish is understandable.
Posted By: Orthodox Catholic Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/17/02 06:05 PM
Dear Amado,

O.K., O.K. . . .

Pochayiv is the Lourdes of the Byzantine Church - how's that?

Does the Indian Shrine have a miraculous spring of water? smile

If not, then I really don't think it qualifies in the "Lourdes" category. smile

Alex
Posted By: Mor Ephrem Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/17/02 06:27 PM
Dear Alex,

I'm not sure, but I think there is a spring of water at Vailankanni, but I'm open to correction in case I'm wrong.

Dear Amado,

Thanks for the support! smile

As for daily Masses in India, I was always sure that there are those places which celebrate them. Mother Teresa's convents, the Vatican Embassy, shrines and other places. My doubt, and what my mother intended when speaking to me, was with regard to the average, ordinary, Latin parish in India. Certainly the above categories aren't ordinary in any way. Therefore, the question continues, for me anyway.
Posted By: Amadeus Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/17/02 07:17 PM
Dear Professor:

Well, there was/is a water pond and a "tank of milk." There is a Chapel of Our Lady's Tank, aside from the Basilica, built within the Shrine grounds.

Which is more valuable: water or milk? I don't know. wink During the first apparition of our Lady, She asked,and was gladly given by, the little Indian boy milk for Her baby Son!

Involved here, therefore, is Holy Milk! (I just hope that the expression "Holy Cow!" is not a derivation! biggrin

Dear Phillip(single L or double?):

You are welcome!

With around 16 million Indian Catholics, mainly concentrated to the south, I am 99% sure there is at least a single Mass celebrated daily in all of the parishes. (Have you heard that, for the first time I think, an Eastern Catholic bishop in the person of Archbishop Cyril Mar Baselios of Trivandrum, primate of the 400,000 Syro-Malankara Church, was elected President of the Catholic Bishops Conference of India (CBCI) during its biennial meeting held last month?) cool
Posted By: Orthodox Catholic Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/17/02 07:19 PM
Dear Catholicos,

I'm just kidding . . .

This does point to an historical "rivalry" among Churches as to who had the greatest shrines, the most relics etc.

The icon of Pochayiv is beautiful, to be sure. The Mother of God holds the Christ-Child on her right arm and holds a cloth in her other hand.

Some have said she uses that cloth to wipe away the tears of those who come to ask favours of her.

The frame of the icon depicts Sts. Menas of Egypt, Abramius, Barbara and others.

The Pochayiv Icon, as well as the Icon of the Dormition of Kyiv, also represents a unique Slavic expression of devotion to the Mother of God.

The icon is held by two ropes above the Royal, main Doors of the iconostasis in Pochayiv.

After the Liturgy, the icon is lowered down to allow the people to come to kiss it and receive anointing etc.

I have never heard of any other Slavic Church follow this beautiful custom.

Pochayiv probably comes from the river "Pochayna" if this is correct.

It was the centre of a vibrant Orthodox liturgical and catechetical publishing enterprise, something that has been handed down to the St Job of Pochaev Printshop of Jordanville and in the Basilian publishing house of Svitlo.

It also has a great ecumenical significance as its pilgrims have always included Greek, Latin and Armenian Catholics, as well as, of course, Orthodox Christians of many different backgrounds.

I have an antique medal of Pochayiv with the Icon and Footprint on the front and St Job on the back.

Our Lady of Pochayiv is special to all Slavic Orthodox and Byzantine Catholics. So is your special Shrine, and no one is suggesting that one is more than the other.

This reminds me of a discussion a pair of English Catholics had that was repeated often in recusant literature to illustrate an unnecessary point:

"I love Our Lady of York, Sir!"

"And I Our Lady of Glastonbury, dear fellow!"

May the Most Holy Mother of God, glorified in all Her Shrines throughout the world, cover us with Her protective mantle!

Alex
Posted By: Amadeus Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/17/02 07:43 PM
[ 04-17-2002: Message edited by: Amado Guerrero ]
Posted By: Orthodox Catholic Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/17/02 08:03 PM
Dear Amado,

Yes, the miraculous phenomenon of the "milk-like" myrrh is truly amazing!

I received a vial of the Manna of St Nicholas, the oil that exudes from his Relics and which was largely diluted in water.

In a moment of great personal need, I drank some of this clear water with the Oil mixed in.

What I tasted, however, was pure milk.

Also, when my diabetes was taking me on a downward spiral, I read the Psalms as frequently as possible, asking God to help me.

Then, when I got to about Psalm 30, I felt as if milk was poured into me, and I felt it hit my stomach and "slush" around in there!

A wonderful peace and sense of contentment ensued.

But I had the taste of milk in my mouth for some time.

I shared this with my nurse at the diabetic clinic.

She told me that some other diabetic patients have a similar story including the feeling of tasting milk.

Some saints have also suggested that we need to be nourished on the "Milk of Grace" of the Mother of God.

There is an icon depicting the nursing Mother of God called in Greek: Galaktotrophousa. And there is of course Our Lady of La Leche, Patroness of Florida and the U.S.

Alex
Posted By: griego catolico Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/19/02 12:00 AM
Dear Alex,
Christ Is Risen!
Thank you for that information on the icon of Our Lady of Pochayiv!
I first learned about the icon of Our Lady of Pochayiv in 1988, the same year I first learned about the existence of the Byzantine Catholic Church(at that time still "underground" in Ukraine). 1988 also happened to be a Marian year declared by the Church. During that year in Los Angeles, there was a big Marian event in the Hollywood Bowl and an enlarged image of the Pochayiv icon was selected to be the Marian image displayed for the event.

Also, there was mention of the miracle of Our Lady of Pochayiv in an article about Ukraine in an issue of National Geographic magazine.

Since then it is my dream to one day make a pilgrimage to the Pochayiv monastery. I had the opportunity to see the original icon of Our Lady of Pochayiv as well as the second Pochayiv icon and Our Lady's footprint from seeing the video, "A Vision of Freedom."

I do have a small Pochayiv icon in my room.

Here in Los Angeles, there is an absolutely gorgeous copy of the Pochayiv icon (with diamond crowns!) enshrined in Saint Nicholas' Antiochian Orthodox Cathedral. Sometimes I have visited the cathedral just to pray before the icon.

Personally I believe the monastery should be handed over to the Basilians again, but as one Ukrainian seminarian said when I brought up the subject: "There would be war. The Orthodox Church would never want to let the monastery go."

All the more reason to pray for unity!

God bless you,
griego catolico
Posted By: Orthodox Catholic Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/19/02 01:02 PM
Dear Griego,

You are welcome and it is always heart-warming to hear of such great devotion to the Most Holy Mother of God in Her miraculous icons and images!

Pochayiv, though, is an Orthodox monastery and so it should remain.

The "take-over" of the Lavra was a sorry event in the history of the relations between our Churches and Metropolitan Andrew maintained a strictly "hands-off" policy here.

The Basilians at Pochayiv, unfortunately, promoted a very pro-Latinization agenda at Pochayiv, to the point of introducing statues etc.

Although St Job was a glorified Orthodox saint, they simply shut up his relics to prevent pilgrimages from taking place.

When both Orthodox and Catholics didn't stop coming there to pray before his Shrine, the Basilians then introduced his actual canonization cause at Rome, as noted extensively in the book "The Holy Pochayivska Lavra" by Met. Ilarion Ohienko, complete with photocopies of letters sent back and forth between the Pochayiv Basilians and the Roman Church authorities.

The Pochayiv icon was crowned with a papal crown, one of only a handful of such Eastern icons to receive it.

When His Holiness visited Ukraine, he gave the papal crown to the miraculous icon of Terebovlya which is in St George's Cathedral I believe, and also two others for locally venerated miraculous icons there.

Alex
Posted By: griego catolico Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/19/02 07:44 PM
Thank you again Alex for the new information.

Here is a link that leads to a great website on the Pochayiv monastery:


www.iprinet.kiev.ua/wumag/archiv/1_99/pochayiv.htm [iprinet.kiev.ua]

[ 04-19-2002: Message edited by: griego catolico ]
Posted By: Chtec Re: Our Lady of Pochaev in PA! - 04/25/02 07:32 PM
Official Announcement Regarding the Pochaev/Pochaiv Icon [oca.org]
© The Byzantine Forum